A Singular Surface In Three Dimensions

If the animation does not appear, click here.

This animation depicts a surface which has a peculiar singularity. (See notes below.)


The surface shown here is given by the equation z = 5 x2 y ⁄ (x4 + y2). The singularity at the origin has a very interesting nature: The limit of z as (x, y) → (0, 0) along lines of the form y = m x, where we have z = 5 m x ⁄ (x2 + m2), is always zero. Nevertheless, the limit of z as (x, y) → (0, 0) does not exist. To see this consider what happens to z as (x, y) → (0, 0) along parabolae of the form y = m x2. Along such parabolae, we have z = 5 m ⁄ (1 + m2).

If we put z = 0 at the origin, we obtain an example of a function which is discontinuous at the origin but for which the directional derivatives at the origin exist in every direction. (07/27/07)